Getting Jurors to Talk | PowerHouse Insights
PowerHouse
INSIGHTS

Trial Practice   /   Voir Dire

Getting Jurors
to Talk

Six practical ways to ask better questions, make room for honest answers, and follow up when something matters.

People seated in two rows in a courtroom jury box

“Can everyone be fair?” The room goes quiet. A few people nod. It would be easy to thank the panel and move on, but imagine being the person who has to raise a hand and explain, in front of strangers, why the honest answer might be “I’m not sure.”

Getting jurors to talk starts with giving them a question they can answer in their own words. Then we have to make room for the answer, especially when it’s one we weren’t expecting. Here are six things you can practice before your next voir dire.

Start with an experience people can describe

In a civil case involving an injury that may be hard to see, consider starting with a broad question about experience. “Has anyone had to make sense of a health problem that was hard to see or measure?” A show of hands gives you a place to begin. Then ask, “What made that experience easy or difficult to understand?” One person may talk about a test result. Another may describe what they noticed when someone close to them stopped doing ordinary things. Those answers tell you what each person paid attention to and give you a natural way to follow up.

Ask the question and give it time

Try asking, “What goes through your mind when you hear that someone has filed a lawsuit over an injury?” Then wait. People may need a moment to decide how to put their thoughts into words or whether they’re comfortable being the first to speak. If you rush in with “Do you think there are too many lawsuits?” you’ve given the panel a particular issue to react to before hearing what came to mind on its own. In rehearsal, ask a colleague to pause before answering so you can get used to leaving that space open.

Follow the words the juror actually uses

Suppose a prospective juror says, “I’d want something objective.” That word is worth a follow-up. “When you say ‘objective,’ what kinds of things would you look for?” One person might mean medical imaging. Another might mean records made close in time or observations from someone who knew the person before the injury. After you understand what the juror means, you can ask how strongly they hold that view. “How might it affect the way you listen to testimony about symptoms that are difficult to measure?”

“When you say ‘objective,’ what kinds of things would you look for?”

Make it safe to disagree

The panel learns how you handle disagreement by watching what happens to the first person who voices it. If someone says, “I think people exaggerate injuries when money is involved,” thank them for saying it plainly. Ask, “What has shaped that view for you?” A quick defense of your client can end the conversation you just opened. Once you’ve heard the answer, invite a second perspective with “Who sees this differently or has had a different experience?” Give the next speaker the same attention you gave the first.

Give quieter people a way into the conversation

Once a few people have spoken, it’s easy to keep returning to them. Bring someone else in with a specific invitation. “Ms. Rivera, we’ve heard a couple of ways people think about medical records. What do you tend to look for when you’re trying to understand an injury?” Give the juror room to say they haven’t had that experience. If the topic turns personal, ask the court how it would like to handle any sensitive follow-up before pressing for details in front of the panel.

Prepare a sequence you can leave when an answer matters

For each topic, write an opening question, a follow-up that clarifies the answer, and a question about how that experience or belief might affect the juror’s consideration of the case. Practice within the time and procedures the judge has set. If your practice partner gives an unexpected answer, follow it for a question or two before returning to your outline. That rehearsal prepares you for the moment when what a juror just said deserves more attention than your next planned question.

When you finish a practice round, ask your colleague which question made it easiest to answer honestly and when they felt you were waiting to get back to your outline. Pay particular attention to what you did after an answer surprised you. That’s a moment you can practice now so you’re ready to listen when it happens in court.

Share this: