Mediation / Practical Guide
How to Prepare
for Mediation
Ten practical steps to clarify what matters, evaluate your options, and make decisions at the table.
One of the hardest times to decide what you can live with is when an offer is on the table and everyone is waiting for an answer. Give yourself a head start by thinking through those decisions before mediation begins.
A mediator helps people identify what is keeping them apart, explore possible agreements, and work through the decisions in front of them. The people involved decide whether to settle. Whether you’re preparing for a business dispute, a family matter, or a disagreement with a neighbor, these ten steps can help you arrive ready to use the time well.
Step 1Decide what you want to accomplish
Write down what you hope to accomplish and put those goals in order. If payment matters, think about the timing as well as the amount. If the parties will continue working together or living next door, consider what would make that relationship workable after mediation. Ranking your goals gives you a way to evaluate an offer that meets some of them.
Step 2Organize the facts and documents
Start with a short timeline and the documents that answer the questions likely to come up. If the dispute involves an unpaid invoice, for example, flag the invoice, the agreement, and the email approving the work. Ask your lawyer or the mediator what should be provided in advance and how to submit it.
Step 3Get clear about what’s behind your request
You might ask for payment in full because you need enough cash to pay a vendor this month. Once you identify that immediate need, you can assess whether an initial payment and a realistic installment plan would work. Knowing why a term matters makes it easier to evaluate an offer that looks different from the one you had in mind.
Step 4Anticipate the other side’s concerns
Write down the strongest point you expect the other side to make. What fact might they see differently? What concern might explain a term they’re likely to insist on? You may still disagree, but you’ll have had time to think about how to respond and what information might move the conversation forward.
Step 5Plan what you want to say and ask
Think about what you want the mediator and the other side to understand. Explain the effect of what happened in specific terms. For example, “When the delivery date changed, we had to reschedule two crews” gives people something concrete to discuss. When you hear an unexpected proposal, try asking what problem it is meant to solve before you respond.
Step 6Work out what happens without an agreement
Your best alternative to a negotiated agreement, often called your BATNA, is the most realistic option you have if you leave without a deal. Ask what that option would take in time, money, and effort, and where the uncertainties are. Use that assessment to weigh an actual offer, including its timing and terms.
Step 7Give yourself room to think
Identify the subjects that are likely to be difficult and discuss how you want to handle them. If you need a break to speak privately with your lawyer or think through a proposal, ask for one. Leave some room in your schedule so your next appointment doesn’t become part of the negotiation.
Step 8Choose a mediator who fits the dispute
If you have a say in the selection, consider the mediator’s experience with the issues and ask how they would structure the session. A dispute involving several decision-makers may call for different preparation than a dispute between people who will need to keep working together.
Step 9Plan for follow-up
A productive session can uncover a missing document, a calculation that needs checking, or an approval someone needs to obtain. If you need more time, try to leave with a clear understanding of who will do what and when you’ll reconnect.
Step 10Decide what advice you’ll need
Talk with your lawyer in advance about the decisions you may face and the terms you want to review carefully. If a proposed agreement could affect taxes, a business, or a financial arrangement, consider who can help you evaluate those terms and how you’ll reach them if a question comes up during mediation.
Good preparation gives you a way to think clearly when the conversation takes an unexpected turn. You can listen to a new idea, ask the questions that matter, and decide whether the agreement in front of you is one you can live with.